Wine ShopBrooklyn, NY
YORK CELLARS LLC
A Italy-leaning shop — value-forward.
www.yorkcellars.comValue-Forward
56
wines on the list
100%
with a price
6
vintages
$21
median price
51/ 100
Program Score
Notable
preliminary · v1
Selection60
56 wines on the list
Range39
spans 2 of 4 price tiers · $18–$26 core
Depth55
6 vintages (2018–2025)
Preliminary grade from the observed list. Selection, range, and depth are computed from every line; distinctiveness, sourcing, and provenance dimensions are added as canonical resolution and peer coverage fill in.
Among peers
vs the 34 wine shops we observe
#29of 34 wine shops
Outscores 15% of peers — top 85%
Selection
18th pct
Range
6th pct
Depth
27th pct
Percentile among observed wine shops, by score dimension. Cohort grows as more lists are added.
Taste fingerprint
the shape of the program, at a glance
Old World82% Old World
Sparkling1 sparkling
Premium$21 median
Breadth10 regions · 8 grapes
Natural4 orange · 1 rosé
Cellar2018–2025
Vintage depth
6 vintages · 98% dated
Price architecture
56 priced · 100% of list
Min$7
25th$18
Median$21
75th$26
Max$60
Entry$0–$25
39
Core$25–$60
17
Premium$60–$150
0
Cellar$150+
0
Character
80% of lines characterised from the title
Color mix
Red
15
White
4
Orange
4
Rosé
1
+ 1 sparkling
Goes deep in 4 countries
California5Portugal4Tuscany4Piedmont3Northern Italy2Beaujolais2Languedoc-Roussillon2Loire2Jura2Veneto1
Grapes named most
Sauvignon Blanc5Pinot Noir4Cabernet Sauvignon2Chenin Blanc1Chardonnay1Sangiovese1Nebbiolo1Syrah1
Observed wine list
The list
| Wine | Vintage | Price | Matched |
|---|---|---|---|
| Windisch, Dornfelder (Sweet Wine) 2024 | 2024 | $14 | Unresolved |
| Christina, 'Kuhlbar' Chillable Red 2024 | 2024 | $18 | Unresolved |
| Dean Creek, Estate Shiraz 2021 | 2021 | $16 | Unresolved |
| Zorzal, Malbec 'Gran Terroir' Tupungato 2024 $21.99 | 2024 | $22 | Unresolved |
| Santa Julia, 'El Burro' Malbec Natural 2024 $20.99 | 2024 | $21 | Unresolved |
| Altos las Hormigas, Malbec Clasico Mendoza 2023 $15.99 | 2023 | $16 | Unresolved |
| Carmelo Patti, Malbec 2019 $40.99 | 2019 | $41 | Unresolved |
| Durigutti, Malbec Mendoza 2024 $17.99 | 2024 | $18 | Unresolved |
| California Stars, 'Star Crossed' Red 2023 $21.99 | 2023 | $22 | Unresolved |
| Christina, 'Kuhlbar' Chillable Red 2024 $17.99 | 2024 | $18 | Unresolved |
| G.D. Vajra, Langhe Nebbiolo 2024 [Half-Bottle] - 375mL $17.99 | 2024 | $18 | Unresolved |
| Bovio, Barolo DOCG La Morra 2021 $52.99 | 2021 | $53 | Unresolved |
| Cantina del Taburno, 'Fidelis' Aglianico Sannio 2018 $16.99 | 2018 | $17 | Unresolved |
| Voerzio Martini, Barolo La Morra 2019 $54.99 | 2019 | $55 | Unresolved |
| Ridge, 'Three Valleys' Sonoma County 2023 $35.99 | 2023 | $36 | Unresolved |
| Fossil & Fawn, 'Do Nothing' Red 2024 $25.99 | 2024 | $26 | Unresolved |
| Erste & Neue, Lagrein 2023 $19.99 | 2023 | $20 | Unresolved |
| Jolie-Laide, 'Glou D' Etat' Red 2024 $24.99 | 2024 | $25 | Unresolved |
| Isabelle Suire, Saumur Rouge 2023 $23.99 | 2023 | $24 | Unresolved |
| Cerbaiona, 'Grammatica' Sangiovese Toscana IGT 2023 $32.99 | 2023 | $33 | Unresolved |
| Ciavolich, Montepulciano D'Abruzzo 2023 $19.99 | 2023 | $20 | Unresolved |
| Stirm, 'Benitoite' San Benito Red 2023 $28.99 | 2023 | $29 | Unresolved |
| Niepoort, 'Nat Cool' Baga Bairrada Red 2024 - 1L $19.99 | 2024 | $20 | Unresolved |
| Domaine Rolet, Arbois Rouge 'Tradition' 2023 $28.99 | 2023 | $29 | Unresolved |
| Les Athletes du Vin, Pineau d'Aunis 2024 $23.99 | 2024 | $24 | Unresolved |
| Robert Sinskey, 'Point of View' Napa Valley 2018 $59.99 | 2018 | $60 | Unresolved |
| Scar of the Sea, Pinot Noir 'SLO' Coast 2025 $33.99 | 2025 | $34 | Unresolved |
| Puech Redon, 'Apparente' Languedoc Rouge 2023 $20.99 | 2023 | $21 | Unresolved |
| Chateau Cambon, Beaujolais 2023 $25.99 | 2023 | $26 | Unresolved |
| Rabasco, Cancelli Rosso Montepulciano 2025 $25.99 | 2025 | $26 | Unresolved |
| J. Hofstatter, 'Meczan' Sudtirol Pinot Noir 2024 $19.99 | 2024 | $20 | Unresolved |
| Comtesse Marion, Cabernet Sauvignon Pays d'Oc 2025 $15.99 | 2025 | $16 | Unresolved |
| Niepoort, 'Nat Cool' Baga Bairrada Red 2024 - 1L $19.99 | 2024 | $20 | Unresolved |
| Domaine Rolet, Arbois Rouge 'Tradition' 2023 $28.99 | 2023 | $29 | Unresolved |
| Les Athletes du Vin, Pineau d'Aunis 2024 $23.99 | 2024 | $24 | Unresolved |
| Robert Sinskey, 'Point of View' Napa Valley 2018 $59.99 | 2018 | $60 | Unresolved |
| Comtesse Marion, Chardonnay Pays d'Oc 2025 $14.99 | 2025 | $15 | Unresolved |
| Prisma, Sauvignon Blanc CAN 2025 - 250mL $6.99 | 2025 | $7 | Unresolved |
| Castello di Tassarolo, Gavi 'Orsola' 2024 $19.99 | 2024 | $20 | Unresolved |
| Scar of the Sea, Pinot Noir 'SLO' Coast 2025 $33.99 | 2025 | $34 | Unresolved |
| Lauverjat, Val de Loire Sauvignon Blanc 2024 $24.99 | 2024 | $25 | Unresolved |
| Bonny Doon, 'Le Cigare' Orange 2024 $17.99 | 2024 | $18 | Unresolved |
| Quinta do Ermizio, Vinho Verde 2025 $18.99 | 2025 | $19 | Unresolved |
| Puech Redon, 'Apparente' Languedoc Rouge 2023 $20.99 | 2023 | $21 | Unresolved |
| Chateau Cambon, Beaujolais 2023 $25.99 | 2023 | $26 | Unresolved |
| Rabasco, Cancelli Rosso Montepulciano 2025 $25.99 | 2025 | $26 | Unresolved |
| Where's Linus?, Orange Mendocino Sauvignon Blanc 2024 $17.99 | 2024 | $18 | Unresolved |
| J. Hofstatter, 'Meczan' Sudtirol Pinot Noir 2024 $19.99 | 2024 | $20 | Unresolved |
| Comtesse Marion, Cabernet Sauvignon Pays d'Oc 2025 $15.99 | 2025 | $16 | Unresolved |
| Field Recordings, Chenin Blanc 2024 $22.99 | 2024 | $23 | Unresolved |
| Salvatore Marino, 'Turi' Catarratto 2024 $23.99 | 2024 | $24 | Unresolved |
| Brisa Suave, Vinho Verde Rose 2025 - 1L $16.99 | 2025 | $17 | Unresolved |
| Anno Domini, Organic Prosecco Frizzante (NV) $13.99 | NV | $14 | Unresolved |
| Pierre Bories, 'Lo Petit Fantet D'Hippolyte' Blanc 2024 $18.99 | 2024 | $19 | Unresolved |
| Muller-Ruprecht, Orange 2025 $20.99 | 2025 | $21 | Unresolved |
| FUSO, 'CALA' Catarratto Orange 2024 $17.99 | 2024 | $18 | Unresolved |
Run the full Wine List X-Ray for this shop
The complete provenance breakdown, comparable lists, and trade-graph depth — for any wine list you paste or upload.